What’s Wrong With The Walking Dead?


I’m a horror lover. I grew up with George A. Romero and his Night, Dawn, and Day of the Dead. Return of the Living Dead was fun. Dead Alive was a trip. When I was younger I would play war with my G.I. Joe action figures and midway through the dead would rise and the survivors would have to band together to fight off the zombie horde. Zombies have been something I’ve loved for many years.

Let me admit that I never read the comics before watching the show. I did try to read the comics but found them to be…less than stellar. They just weren’t for me. I felt the writing was too obvious and shallow. When characters have to spell out every little thing they do, it’s never a good thing.

Imagine my excitement when I learned a new zombie show was coming to TV! And it was being developed by Frank Darabont, who directed the film, The Mist, which I enjoyed. Like many other horror fans, I couldn’t wait. When the show premiered, I drank it in. I loved the look, the feel, and I especially loved the zombies.

The first season was pretty good. Seeing The Walking Dead on the small screen felt like the beginning of something great.

And then they fired Frank Darabont. Imagine having a successful coach and midway through your best year management decides to can them. The team will probably be affected in some capacity. Check out this Screen Rant article for more details: http://screenrant.com/walking-dead-frank-darabont-amc-aco-127783/

Fast forward to season two. What a stagnant mess of a season. The show’s direction pulled a one eighty focusing mainly on character arcs and group dynamic. Gone was the zombie threat (except when they needed to move the plot along) replaced by typical television drama. That would be fine if the show wasn’t called The Walking Dead.

It’s disappointing because the special effects on this show are fantastic. The costume and wardrobe departments aren’t too shabby either. Whenever zombies are on the screen, they are frighteningly dazzling to behold. The problem is they’re utilized more like props rather than valid threats, or the predators they should be.

It seems like a new show runner is ushered in with each new season. There’s little continuity.

The first half of season three was pretty good, but trailed off into mediocrity after it was announced Glen Mazzara would be let go due to a difference of opinion with executives. It was a shame because I thought he struck a good balance of drama, action, and horror, which this show, and season, so badly needed. This Hollywood Reporter article can explain futher: http://movies.yahoo.com/news/walking-dead-cast-bids-glen-mazzara-farewell-050000308.html;_ylt=A0LEV1DBBCdTrBcAuGFXNyoA;_ylu=X3oDMTEzMGhvY3FxBHNlYwNzcgRwb3MDMgRjb2xvA2JmMQR2dGlkA1ZJUDM1MV8x

Season four gave us yet another new show runner, Scott Gimple, and a few more episodes of the Governor, even though it was clear that whole storyline should have wrapped up by the end of season three. Why the folks running the show felt the need to drag things out is beyond me. Creatively the show suffers. Yet, for some reason, the show gains viewership. The Walking Dead has become the hip show everyone is watching.

Well, almost everyone. When asked to direct an episode, legendary director, George A. Romero, declined. His reason was that he didn’t feel The Walking Dead was a true zombie show. Read more in this Huffington Post article: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/11/01/george-romero-walking-dead-soap-opera_n_4183182.html

After watching last night’s episode (actually, long before that) it’s apparent the writers and producers don’t know what they want. Remember the beginning of season four when that new disease (the one where normal folks turned into zombies after they coughed and their eyes bled) was going to change things? Yeah, that lasted two episodes and was completely forgotten. Remember when the Governor was good, no bad, no really bad, and then took over a group of complete strangers just because he could…and drove a tank to blow up the prison? Why didn’t he do that last season when he had people who would have actually followed him? The constant flip-flopping of character traits and storylines is annoying to say the least.

It’s clear to me that The Walking Dead suffers from a lack of identity. One week it’s a drama, the next it’s horror, and other weeks it’s something else entirely. The characters seem to suffer from the same lack of identity. One week this character acts one way only to act the opposite way shortly after. As a viewer I’m frustrated. As a horror lover I’m torn. I want to like this show. I want to support this show because it’s supposed to be horror. Yet every time I watch, horror seems to be the last thing I see. A couple of gratuitous zombie kills each episode doesn’t make for intelligent horror.

Where does the show go from here? How much longer will fans flock to their televisions despite The Walking Dead’s garish flaws? I don’t think there’s a clear cut answer. All we can do is wait and see.

The new direction of the show seems to have the characters headed toward yet another sanctuary. Apparently they suddenly notice signs for a city that they miraculously never noticed before. Sure, they’ve gone on supply runs all around the prison and for some reason never noticed any signs for a secure city where if you arrive you survive. Nah, they only notice them when the prison is blown to bits and they’re on the run.

You would figure since the safety of the prison is gone a few more characters would have perished. Nope. Even though they may be surrounded by zombies these characters always manage to defy the odds. Even Glenn, when barely conscious after his bout with the mystery sickness and could barely walk, somehow managed to put on riot gear and push his way through hundreds of zombies in the blazing Georgia heat. I could go on and on with some of the ridiculous things these characters do on a weekly basis, which is a shame.

I think many horror fans have grown tired of The Walking Dead’s antics. I stopped watching during the second season only to return after they left the farm. Too bad the show seems to have taken another turn for the worse. Season four has been a huge disappointment for me as a horror lover. I’ve been fooled into coming back once. I won’t be fooled into coming back a second time.

The show has become too safe, the zombies too tame. A zombie show without believable zombies is just a drama. And that’s exactly what The Walking Dead has become, just another drama.

As for me, I’m waiting for FX’s The Strain to hit the small screen this summer. Hopefully predatory vampires will be able to do what AMC’s The Walking Dead has failed to do thus far: Make viewers afraid.



  1. Ugh, I basically agree. I gave up on TWD in the early part of season 3, and I haven’t gone back. Sad truth: I don’t miss it at all. I think being a horror fan makes me less tolerant of this show’s flaws, not more. When horror finally hits the mainstream in as big a way as this TV show has, I want it to be spectacular. Instead, this show disappointed me time and again, so I cut my ties.

  2. Like you, I gave up half way through season 2 and came back once they left the farm. I enjoyed season 3, but agree that the governor should have blown up the prison at the end of that season instead of drawing it out. Despite its flaws, I admit I still watch every week. Why? I’m compelled to see where the writers are taking it. There are still episodes that surprise me, although fewer this season than last, and I’m curious about Terminus and the people Glenn has hooked up with. Will they eventually take the scientist guy to DC? I am annoyed that they’ve split the group up in such a way that it takes three or four episodes to get back to a story thread. Although I agree that being scattered like that would make it almost impossible to find each other again, it does seem like most of them are traveling by rail to Terminus, so either kill off more of the group or bring them together faster. Or at least have the stories overlap in each episode. Also, are all the cars wrecked now? It seems they were able to find vehicles pretty easy before. Wouldn’t it be quicker to get to Terminus this way? Despite its flaws, I’ll still be tuning in next week. Can’t help myself.

  3. I’ve only seen a few episodes but it’s like a soap opera with trophy kills of harmless zombies now and again. I don’t do soap operas. And honestly, half the people I know watch the show because they think someone is hot.
    *head desk*
    But I’m so glad you said all of this out loud cuz I figured I didn’t have the right, seeing as how I’ve only seen like seven random episodes or something. 😉

Share your thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s